Kombini and the economics and culture of convenience
Lecture and image notes by Gavin Hamilton Whitelaw for Anthro 254 (2003)
NOTE: The 2005 session on November 28 was broadcast from Tokyo. A streaming version of this is here.
I. Introduction
Image 1: (Lawson at night, Tsukishima – "glow town" Tokyo)
A. Taking convenience stores seriously
For many of us, convenience stores are retail spaces that we take for granted. We seldom think about them when we use them to buy a newspaper or get a carton of milk
pharmacy-convenience stores gas station food marts (Mobil Mart)Pop culture has consumed and repackaged them
Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure features the Circle K Clerks and its Gen-X staff of slackersLike other ubiquitous service sector locations in national and increasingly global economies (e.g., fast food restaurants, supermakets, department stores, auto dealers), we tend to assume that convenience stores are everywhere alike. This is not so, and Japan's convenience store industry is a case in point.
B. The konbini adds further texture to several of our course themes
1. The relationship of the modern and the traditional2. Themes of family, work, education
"family" run stores, often owned and operated by couples which support busy workers and families reflect part-time labor and changing patterns of work education; a key to the store's success has been a competent work force able to use equipment, collect data, and comply – at least to some significant extent – to the rules set down by the convenience store managers3. Globalization and domestication
C. Konbini also introduce a dimension that until now has been mostly alluded to – consumption.
II. History of retail in Japan
(images from Dentsu website @ www.dentsu.com)
A. Edo period beginnings
Image 2: 1858 Hiroshige
yamakujira (mountain whale = wild board meat) and maruyaki jusanri (whole-cooked imo, better than kuri, chestnuts)Image 3: Mitsukoshi/Mitsui flier of women shopping for kimono fabric
Osaka – Edo connection stores grow larger and begin premodern gchainsh (often involving intermarriage of wholesaler and distributor families) specialty stores expand into department stores floors featuring different items, often sites where Western goods are first displayed and soldImage 4, Image 5 & Image 7: Mitsukoshi lions at Ginza store
department store model imported from Europe merchant delegations visiting London to look at department stores first department store architecture show that they were meant to be a different kind of shopping experience modern consumption and social space (museums, restaurants, cafes inside) Mitsukoshi still has lions, a copy of Harrods of London, but the lions are also curiously like the guardian dog diets outside of Shinto shrines – open and closed mouths due to resistance on the part of small shop owners, corporations building department stores at the terminals of train lines (also an idea that was used in U.S. by certain railroad companies); example Kintetsu, Keio interaction between state and business, linking work to consumerismImage 6: woodblock of items under glass display
"Mise" (from miseru = to show) Store clerks playing important role; items seen, identified then fetched from shelf by clerk behind counter. Kept shop lifting (by customers) at a minimum and prevented soiling and damage Contrast with today's stores where customer does most of the workImage 8 & Image 9: catalogs and specialty soap
importance of using print media to draw in customers rose scented soap as a specialty product of Mitsukoshi (see konbini specialty items like Lawson tea)Image 10: woodblock of old and new stores
not just a sudden conversion of old to new but rather a contentious process of development and change merchant guilds and distributors formed tight political units Daitenho and various revisions keep the bigger department stores from setting in small neighborhood communities
B. The twentieth-century Mom-and-Pop
Image Series: 37-38-39: Yamazaki Store, Kushibiki-machi, Yamagata-ken
"Full Moon Lunch" provides a detailed look at the life of a Tokyo Mom-and-Pop [see also this video clip]
Image 11, Image 12, Image 13, & Image 14: Hiranō-ya, Hirosei-cho, Shimane-ken
C. Rōten – Street Stalls
Image 15 & Image 16: Tsukishima Kusaichi (matsuri)
D. Small-scale enterprise has been interest to anthropologists
E. Convenience Stores (Images 18-23 illustrate a history of 7-Eleven
III. Globalization and Domestication
A. Particular set of cultural, economic, and political conditions have shaped the trajectory and growth of konbini
B. Not kintarō ame
C. Globalization and localization studies
D. Domestication takes different forms in Japan
IV. The nationalization of konbini in Japan
A. 51,000 konbini nation wide; over 60 chains – some national, others regional
B. Big three: 7-Eleven (10,002 stores!), Lawson, FamilyMart
C. Competition is intense
D. This darkness may be part of the reason for growing genre of konbini murder mysteries (Image 42: Konbini Lullaby)
V. Closing points
A. In the U.S. convenience stores are sometimes the first foothold that immigrants have in setting up a business. Will konbini provide a similar function in Japan in the future?
B. konbini are important spaces through which to observe new actors in Japanese society